Blog

Which is Better for Your Sleep: Comforts vs. Weighted Blankets?

by Ann Ferguson

When it comes to getting a good night's sleep, it’s not just your mattress that’s essential — it’s your bedding, too! But it’s more than finding the softest thing to snuggle under; you need to find the best option that leads you to good sleep. So, the question is, should you get a standard comforter or a weighted blanket?

Each has benefits and drawbacks, but how do they stack up against each other? That’s what we’re here for! We’ll explore the pros and cons of comforters vs. weighted blankets so you can make the best choice for your precious slumber!

Cozy Comforters: The Classic Choice

Woman sitting comfortable in bed with a comforter around her

Comforters are the classic choice — they’ve been around for ages! From down to feathers to synthetic fibers, comforters are filled with enough comfy materials to keep you in snooze-land. But are they the right fit?

  • Pros for Sleep:
    • Light and Airy: Comforters provide a more lightweight cover that doesn’t constrict you while you sleep, perfect for sleepers who move around a lot during the night.
    • Warmth Without Overheating: They provide warmth without the risk of overheating, ideal for those who tend to sleep hot.
    • Versatility in Design: With various thicknesses and materials, comforters can suit various seasonal needs, making them a flexible bedding option.
  • Cons for Sleep:
    • Lack of Pressure: Unlike weighted blankets, comforters don't offer the gentle, even pressure that some people find soothing for anxiety or sleep disorders.
    • Potential for Allergens: Depending on the filling, comforters can harbor allergens like dust mites, which might affect sleep quality, especially for those with allergies.

Weighted Blankets: Embracing the Hug

Cat sitting on top of knitted weighted blanket

After exploring the light and airy world of comforters, let's turn to the unique embrace of weighted blankets. Growing in popularity, these blankets aren't just about warmth; they offer a comforting weight that many find soothing. Are they the snug solution for your sleep?

  • Pros for Sleep:
    • Stress and Anxiety Relief: The key feature of weighted blankets is their ability to provide deep pressure touch, which studies have shown can reduce anxiety and promote a sense of calm, helping you fall asleep faster and more peacefully.
    • Targeted Sleep Support: These blankets are especially beneficial for individuals with conditions like insomnia, ADHD, or autism, as the weight helps minimize restlessness and improve overall sleep quality.
    • Enhanced Sleep Quality: The evenly distributed weight can promote a deeper sleep cycle, increasing the chances of feeling well-rested and refreshed.
  • Cons for Sleep:
    • Care and Maintenance: Heavier and requiring special care, weighted blankets can be more challenging to clean and maintain than traditional comforters.
    • Warmth Considerations: Their density and materials can lead to overheating, which might be a concern if you sleep hot.
    • Investment Cost: Typically, weighted blankets are pricier than standard comforters, making them a more significant investment in your sleep setup.

Allergies and Your Bedding: Choosing Wisely

For allergy sufferers, the right bedding is crucial for a sneeze-free sleep. Both comforters and weighted blankets come in hypoallergenic varieties, designed to minimize your nighttime sniffles. When picking a comforter, look for synthetic fills or natural allergen-resistant materials instead of down. In weighted blankets, glass beads or hypoallergenic poly pellets are excellent choices, as they are less likely to stir up allergies.

Remember, cleanliness is vital! Regularly washing your bedding (in hot water, preferable) can make a massive difference with your nighttime allergies!

Decision Time

Comparison of someone sleeping under a comforter vs. a weighted blanket

So, after seeing the pros and cons of comforters and weighted blankets, which should you choose? It all depends on your personal preference and sleep style!

  • Sleeping Style: Side sleepers may benefit more from softer comforters that don’t provide a lot of pressure; back and stomach sleepers will benefit more from the even pressure distribution of a weighted blanket.
  • Temperature Control: Hot sleepers should look for lighter comforters made from cotton or bamboo, although there are weighted blankets with cooling materials. For cooler sleepers, weighted blankets often have insulating materials to keep you warm.
  • Sensory Needs: Those sensitive to texture or pressure should look for comforters with ultra-soft hypoallergenic materials, but if you need more sensory input, a weighted blanket provides more.
Pro Tip:
If you choose a weighted blanket, get one that is 10 percent of your body weight for optimal comfort!

Which Will You Choose?

Now that you know more about the pros and cons, you can decide on the bedding that sets you up for the deep sleep you deserve! However, if the bedding is perfect, but the mattress is far from it, get your upgrade at Van's Home Center! We have mattresses from the top brands in sizes and types that fit your needs!

And if you have any questions about your sleep needs, don’t hesitate to give us a call or drop by! You can count on our sleep experts to steer you in the right direction!